Guide · Digital Commonplace Book

Digital Commonplace Book: How to Keep One You Can Search

A commonplace book is a reader’s collection of passages worth keeping, each with its source, filed under topic headings so you can find them again. People have kept them on paper for centuries, and a digital one fixes what paper never could.

Copying a passage takes seconds instead of minutes, and you can search every entry by a word in it instead of leafing through an index.

Quick answer
  • What it is: a collection of passages you want to keep, each with its source, filed under topic headings.
  • What makes it digital: capture in a click, the source saved with the passage, and a search box instead of an index.
  • For what you read in Chrome: ContextBolt keeps a highlighted passage with its page, adds a topic, and finds it by any word. Basic is free up to 150 bookmarks.
  • For books and your own notes: pair it with a highlights importer for your e-reader and a notes app for your thinking.
  • The habit that makes it work: a weekly review, where you reread the week’s entries and copy the best ones somewhere you will see them.

What a commonplace book is

Yale University Library describes the entries as passages “selected by a reader and arranged under general topic headings like ‘reputation’ or ‘friendship’” in its exhibit on commonplace books.

The historian Robert Darnton traces the habit back to probably the twelfth century, with a peak in the late Renaissance, when schoolboys were taught to keep one. Erasmus, he writes, “instructed them how to do it” (Extraordinary Commonplaces, The New York Review of Books, 2000). Two famous keepers show the range:

  • Thomas Jefferson began his Literary Commonplace Book as early as 1758. By Darnton’s count it holds 407 entries, 339 of them poetry. The manuscript is at the Library of Congress.
  • Isaac Newton took over a large commonplace book his stepfather had started in 1612 and titled it his “Waste Book.” Cambridge University Library, which holds it, says he “invented the method of fluxions, or calculus” in its pages (Cambridge Digital Library).

Every entry has the same three parts: the words, where they came from, and a heading that says what they are about. A bookmark keeps only the second.

John Locke’s index

The hard part of a commonplace book was never writing entries. It was finding them again, because a notebook filed by date is useless when you want everything you copied about friendship.

Locke described his fix in French in 1686, and it was published in English in 1706 as A New Method of Making Common-Place-Books. The rule fits in one line of his:

“observe the First Letter, and the Vowel which follows it; for upon these Two Letters depends the whole Use of our Index.”

The index is a grid at the front of the book, with letters down the side and the five vowels across. Every heading goes in the cell for its first letter and the first vowel after it. The cell holds the page number where that heading’s entries live. When you start a new heading, you take the next blank page and write its number in the cell.

HeadingFirst letterFirst vowel after itIndex cell
Epistle (Locke’s own example)EiE i
FriendshipFiF i
ReputationReR e
MoneyMoM o

To find everything on reputation, you go to cell R e, read the page number, and turn to it.

A search box does Locke’s job in a keystroke, and it does one thing his grid could not. It finds an entry by any word inside it, not only by its heading.

Paper or digital?

The strongest case for paper comes from Ryan Holiday’s 2014 post How and Why to Keep a Commonplace Book. His rules:

  • Wait “a week or so” after finishing a book, then go back through your marks and copy what is still worth keeping.
  • Write it by hand: “Actually writing the stuff down is crucial.”
  • Use “4×6 ruled index cards, which Robert Greene introduced me to,” with the theme written in the top right corner.
  • Do not plan your categories in advance: “the themes will reveal themselves.”

He prefers that system to what he calls “some cloud-based shortcut,” and rewriting a passage by hand does make you decide why you kept it.

Digital wins elsewhere. The source comes with the passage automatically, capture takes seconds so you save the line while you are still reading, and search finds an entry by a half-remembered word years later.

You don’t have to choose. Capture digitally as you read, then use Holiday’s weekly wait as a review: reread the week’s entries and copy the best few by hand.

What to use for a digital commonplace book

The right tool depends on where you read, and you may need two or three, one for each source.

Where the passage comes fromWhat to useWhy it fits
Articles and pages in ChromeContextBoltHighlight, save, done. Keeps the passage with its title and address, adds a topic, finds it by any word. Free up to 150 bookmarks.
Posts you bookmark on X, Reddit and LinkedInContextBoltX bookmarks and LinkedIn posts as you save them, Reddit saves when you visit Reddit. All on the Social tab of the same library.
Kindle, Apple Books and Kobo highlightsReadwiseImports from Kindle, Apple, Kobo and 40+ sources. Full plan $9.99 a month billed yearly.
Your own thoughts on what you readObsidian or NotionLong notes and links between them. Obsidian is free.
  • Readwise is built for e-reader highlights. It lists Kindle, Apple and Kobo among 40-plus import sources. The full plan is $9.99 a month billed yearly, or $12.99 monthly, with a 30-day trial.
  • Obsidian is “Free without limits.” It is a strong home for your own writing about what you read.
  • Notion’s web clipper saves whole web pages into Notion, though Notion warns that pages “can’t all be parsed the same way.” Its help page does not mention clipping just a passage you highlighted.

Whichever tools you pick, check that each one keeps the source with the passage and lets you search every entry.

How to set up a commonplace book in ContextBolt

This covers what you read in Chrome, and setup takes about ten minutes, most of which is reading.

  1. Add ContextBolt to Chrome. It is free from the Chrome Web Store, with no account and no card. Pin the icon next to the address bar.
  2. Read as usual. When a passage is worth keeping, select it. Anything from a sentence to a few paragraphs works, as long as it is at least 40 characters.
  3. Click the ContextBolt icon, then Save this page. Because text is selected, it keeps only that passage, with the page’s title and address. The button reads “Highlight saved.”
  4. Let the topics do Locke’s job. Each save gets a topic and a few tags automatically, like the headings in a paper commonplace book. You never file anything by hand.
  5. Find any entry by a word in it. Open your library, switch to the Web tab and type a word you remember. Typos and half words still match, and the result shows the sentence with your words marked. See how searching saved pages works.

Your social saves join the same library. ContextBolt captures X bookmarks as you make them and reads in older ones from your X bookmarks page, syncs your newest 1,000 Reddit saves when you visit Reddit, and adds a Save to ContextBolt button to posts in your LinkedIn feed. They live on the Social tab. Search runs on one tab at a time, so switch tabs to search the other half.

Basic is free and capped at 150 bookmarks. Pro is $6 a month: it removes the cap, adds cloud sync, and adds the MCP connection, so Claude can search your whole library in a conversation. On Pro you can also export everything as CSV, JSON or XLSX, which makes a good yearly backup.

Commonplace book categories and examples

In a digital book the themes form from what you save. If you want a starting set for a paper book or a weekly review, these headings cover a lot of reading: work and craft, decisions, money, health, writing, people and relationships, learning, places, quotes worth repeating, and things to try.

An entry needs the words, the source and a heading. Here is one from this post in that shape:

“observe the First Letter, and the Vowel which follows it; for upon these Two Letters depends the whole Use of our Index.”

John Locke, A New Method of Making Common-Place-Books (1706), archive.org. Topic: Learning. Tags: #locke, #indexing.

A weekly review keeps it alive

A commonplace book you never reread is a pile, the same problem as a folder of bookmarks. The fix is small.

  1. Once a week, open your library and look at the week’s saves on the Web tab.
  2. Reread them. Delete anything that no longer earns its place.
  3. Copy the two or three best into a notebook or a note, in your own words if you can. That is where Holiday’s handwriting rule pays off.

Start with the next passage worth keeping: highlight it, save it, and find it again by a word in it.

Where next

Frequently asked questions

Something else on your mind? Get in touch.

What is a commonplace book?

A notebook of passages worth keeping from what you read, each with its source, filed under topic headings so you can find them again. The habit goes back centuries and peaked in the late Renaissance. Thomas Jefferson kept one, and John Locke published a method for indexing them.

What is the best app for a digital commonplace book?

It depends where you read. For articles and posts in Chrome, ContextBolt keeps a highlighted passage with the page's title and address, files it under a topic and finds it by any word in it. Basic is free up to 150 bookmarks. For your own thoughts on what you read, add a notes app.

How do I organize a commonplace book?

File each entry under a short topic heading, and keep the source with it. On paper, John Locke's index (the first letter of the heading plus its first vowel) tells you which page to turn to. In a digital version, topics and a search box do that job.

Should a commonplace book be digital or on paper?

Both work. Paper makes you slow down and rewrite the idea, which Ryan Holiday argues is the point. Digital wins on capture and search: copying takes seconds, the source comes with it, and you can find any entry by a word in it. A good middle path is to capture digitally and copy the best entries by hand each week.

Can my X bookmarks be part of a commonplace book?

Yes. A saved post is a commonplace entry with the source attached. ContextBolt captures X bookmarks as you make them, syncs your Reddit saves when you visit Reddit, and saves LinkedIn posts with its own button. They sit on the library's Social tab, next to the web passages on its Web tab.